Post by Bighouserulez on May 7, 2019 14:38:00 GMT -5
Good catch on Rogers have no idea how i missed him.
Hitchcock is the man at C of course so let's use him as the barometer
Hitch
214 GP 213 GS 527/1438 36.6 % 116 pancakes 34 SA 7542 PPlays 5911 Rplays
Polk
215 GP 209 GS 513/1322 38.8 % 79 pancakes 34 SA 7477 PPlays 5889 Rplays
Rogers -5 rings has to yell at me too
193 GP 187 GS 470/1134 41.4 % 78 pancakes 30 SA 6225 Pplays 5973 Rplays
They are sooo close. I would put Polk slightly higher in the stats departmant myself but that 5 rings for Rogers really makes him HOF worthy on the same level.
GUrley is a tough one this is JUST rbs=
AP yards 1 Chamberlain 2 Gurley 3 Rawls
Tds Chamberlain 203 Rawls 187 Upshaw 107 Hayes 100 GUrley is only at 88
Avg YPG 1 Gurley 163 Rawls 145 Anniston 141 Henson 134
Yards from scrimmage Gurley is 5th all time for Rbs.
Avg yards from scrimmage per game Gurley is 12th with Ty right on his tail.
Gurley only had 6 1000 yard seasons rushing.
He only had 1 double digit rushing Td season
He only had 40 100 yard rushing games in 155 GP.
Gurley 698/490 6th in targets/6th in catches 7th in Rb receiving yards 6th in Rb receiving Tds 5th in 100 yard games which is really 3 in 155 GP.
OK so why is he in this talk is because of his PR yards quite honestly-
Prs 14th all time in punt returns 15th in PR yards 0 Tds
KRs 1st all time in kick returns 293 and not close as number two is 235 for a RB 1st in yards 8126 for 27.7 avg 4th best avg and 4 tds is tied with two others.
In my opinion Gurley was a great player that did it all but was not elite or HOF based on those KR numbers are where he moves from just a good back to a great player.
Ug the WR convo i am not ready for. I just get all into Davidson but let's look at the Y/pt that everyone is talking about-
players with at least 100 games and 500 catches
1 Caden SInclair
2 Carlos Johnson
3 Lewis Lochtfeld
4 Markus Wheaton
5 Justin Hunter
6 Mike Evans
7 Tyler Lockett
8 Owen Grayville
9 Cameron Henry
OK let's look at yards per game from Wrs-
min 100 games
1 Caden Sinclari
2 Al Shelton
3 Clayton Battle
4 Owen Grayville
5 Rickey Davidson
6 Julio JOnes
14th Justin Hunter
15th Mike Evans
OK so let's talk about 100 yard games
1 Al Shelton
2 Owen Grayville
3 Rickey Davidson
4 Clayton Battle
5 Caiden Sinclair
6 Skip Samuels
7 Odell Beckham
8 Mike Evans
12 Justin HUnter
Let's look at TDs for WRs-
Garyville 110
Battle
Sinclair
Shelton
Jeffery Samuels
17th Justin HUnter
Mike Evans is not on the 1st page and Hunter has 71 to Evans 58
I think the Wrs that are elite in this league if you want the top of the crop IMO-
Grayville
Shelton
Sinclair
Battle
Davidson
The next level which is a drop off IMO
Samuels
Beckham
Evans
Jeffrey
Julio
HUnter
Hitchcock is the man at C of course so let's use him as the barometer
Hitch
214 GP 213 GS 527/1438 36.6 % 116 pancakes 34 SA 7542 PPlays 5911 Rplays
Polk
215 GP 209 GS 513/1322 38.8 % 79 pancakes 34 SA 7477 PPlays 5889 Rplays
Rogers -5 rings has to yell at me too
193 GP 187 GS 470/1134 41.4 % 78 pancakes 30 SA 6225 Pplays 5973 Rplays
They are sooo close. I would put Polk slightly higher in the stats departmant myself but that 5 rings for Rogers really makes him HOF worthy on the same level.
GUrley is a tough one this is JUST rbs=
AP yards 1 Chamberlain 2 Gurley 3 Rawls
Tds Chamberlain 203 Rawls 187 Upshaw 107 Hayes 100 GUrley is only at 88
Avg YPG 1 Gurley 163 Rawls 145 Anniston 141 Henson 134
Yards from scrimmage Gurley is 5th all time for Rbs.
Avg yards from scrimmage per game Gurley is 12th with Ty right on his tail.
Gurley only had 6 1000 yard seasons rushing.
He only had 1 double digit rushing Td season
He only had 40 100 yard rushing games in 155 GP.
Gurley 698/490 6th in targets/6th in catches 7th in Rb receiving yards 6th in Rb receiving Tds 5th in 100 yard games which is really 3 in 155 GP.
OK so why is he in this talk is because of his PR yards quite honestly-
Prs 14th all time in punt returns 15th in PR yards 0 Tds
KRs 1st all time in kick returns 293 and not close as number two is 235 for a RB 1st in yards 8126 for 27.7 avg 4th best avg and 4 tds is tied with two others.
In my opinion Gurley was a great player that did it all but was not elite or HOF based on those KR numbers are where he moves from just a good back to a great player.
Ug the WR convo i am not ready for. I just get all into Davidson but let's look at the Y/pt that everyone is talking about-
players with at least 100 games and 500 catches
1 Caden SInclair
2 Carlos Johnson
3 Lewis Lochtfeld
4 Markus Wheaton
5 Justin Hunter
6 Mike Evans
7 Tyler Lockett
8 Owen Grayville
9 Cameron Henry
OK let's look at yards per game from Wrs-
min 100 games
1 Caden Sinclari
2 Al Shelton
3 Clayton Battle
4 Owen Grayville
5 Rickey Davidson
6 Julio JOnes
14th Justin Hunter
15th Mike Evans
OK so let's talk about 100 yard games
1 Al Shelton
2 Owen Grayville
3 Rickey Davidson
4 Clayton Battle
5 Caiden Sinclair
6 Skip Samuels
7 Odell Beckham
8 Mike Evans
12 Justin HUnter
Let's look at TDs for WRs-
Garyville 110
Battle
Sinclair
Shelton
Jeffery Samuels
17th Justin HUnter
Mike Evans is not on the 1st page and Hunter has 71 to Evans 58
I think the Wrs that are elite in this league if you want the top of the crop IMO-
Grayville
Shelton
Sinclair
Battle
Davidson
The next level which is a drop off IMO
Samuels
Beckham
Evans
Jeffrey
Julio
HUnter
