Joel's 100 (first 80)

So, basically, every draft I do this for the top 100-200 players in a notepad. I thought this season it would be interesting to put it up on here, and show you all how I go about my business when evaluating the talent in the draft. I don't use draft analyser's or anything like that, so this does become tedious, but I enjoy playing the game for what it is, and this bit alone is my favourite part of FOF.


1. Bob Frassrand QB 44% A+
     80-90
     Pros: Everything, legit generational talent
     Cons: No scramble ability
     Pro comp: Frank Mason (84)

2. Walter Willis WR 15% A
     80-90
     Pros: Everything again, maxed out al WR bars
     Cons: lack of dev % for that 1st season
     Pro comp: Dalton Dunn (86)

3. Juan Hunter WR 48% A
    70-80
    Pros: The important bars are all there, will be as productive as any WR of all time. Dev % means he could be a WR2 by week 1, WR1 by the end of the season.
    Cons: End isn't great, just about it really, but it is important.
    Pro comp: Christopher Howe (76)

4. Gabe Thomason WR 25% A
    70-80
    Pros: The important bars are all there, will be as productive as any WR of all time. Dev % means he can be a WR2 by the end of the season.
    Cons: RR isn't full, and dev% holds him back to start week 1 as a productive member.
    Pro comp: Benjamin Kasica (79)

5. Jonathan Hatcher RB 36% A
    70-80
    Pros: Elite every down back, and has the essential max HR, enough End to give 20 carries a game
    Cons: He's a RB, you are taking a chance on a high value pick for maybe only 3-4 elite seasons.   
    Pro comp: Honestly no one in the league, highly dependant on any interview.

6. Shawn Shelby LT 38% A-
    75-85
    Pros: max RB, Static and End, not dumb
    Cons: Not max PB, not super smart
    Pro comp: Marc Bullock (85) just smarter

7. Trevor Elliott LB 41% B+
    75-85
    Pros: Elite across the board, can defend the run, rush the pass and defend the pass
    Cons: Age, bit old
    Pro comp: Earnest Blackburn (79)

8. Sand Castle Caldwell DE 41% B+
    70-80
    Pros: Elite pass rusher and run defender, great size, and End. Also, the guys name.
    Cons: PRS and not going to be super smart
    Pro comp: Cesar Harden +++ (67)

9. Anthony Farrell DE 58% B+
    70-80
    Pros: Elite DE, no weakness for Dline usage
    Cons: End isn't up to par like sand castle.
    Pro comp: Kendrick Rheams (86)

10. Sergio Ohara WR 35% B+
     65-75
     Pros: Elite level RR and BPR, young.
     Cons: GD is not at an elite level, will hold him back on being an every kind of pass WR
     Pro comp: Jimmie Dobbs RETIRED (high 60's)

11. Dixon McCkracken LB 34% B+
      65-75
      Pros: Elite run D and pass rush bars, could possibly have a high level of intel. 
      Cons: Doesn't have the best pass defending bars
      Pro comp: Donnie Delgado (74)

12. Devan Wegert C 19% B+
      75-85
      Pros: Max RB and PB, can carry an OL, 0 sack, 10+ pancake guy. Crazy smart
      Cons: Lacking max end.
      Pro comp: Willie Curtis (peak was 80+)

13. Kenneth Duffy QB 29% B
      55-65
      Pros: Acc bar, SF bar, decent passing bars
      Cons: SR, SR, SR... wouldn't touch, kind of like Moe last season.
      Pro comp: Theodore Moe (65)

14. Sawyer Small RB 46% B
      60-70 
      Pros: Most of his running bars show he could and should be elite.
      Cons: can not catch the ball for shit.
      Pro comp: Johnnie Carlisle (68)

15. Alejandro Whiting RB 61% B
     60-70
     Pros: All around ok, could be a very good receiving option.
     Cons: not max HR, Elu is higher than HR too.
     Pro comp: Jay Brock (68)
 
16. Keagan Rheams WR 34% B
      60-70
      Pros: RR + GD look 75+. Returning ability. Decent dev for a WR
      Cons: static is below 50, not sure I would want to take a shot on him. 
      Pro comp: Brian Rayburn (64)

17. Buddy Richmond LB 17% B-
      55-65
      Pros: great RD and an ability to defend the pass, elite MLB.
      Cons: serious lack of dev, and no ability to rush the passer. 
      Pro comp: Peter Plyer (68)

18. Van Kennedy RB 34% B-
      55-65
      Pros: Max HR and receiving ability
      Cons: End ,ay only end up at around 50, could end up being frustrating seeing him subbed out.
      Pro comp: Levi Buoy (70)

19. Riddick Lyons TE 56% B- 
      60-70
      Pros: BPR is max for a TE, 75+ RR.
      Cons: GD, blocking bars over inflating his bars.
      Pro comp: Giovanni Macri (74) [after seeing this comp, I think I've undervalued him. would want an interview]

20. Joshua Blaine WR 20% B-
      55-65
      Pros: the 3 much needed bars are all 55+, might be worth a gamble late 1st.
      Cons: No elite level bars, a solid WR2 at best
      Pro comp: Wally Brady (59) [Again, think I've overvalued him here, after more comps, he will probably slide down the board a bit]

21. Dusty Newhart DE 48% B-
      60-70
      Pros: Max PRT should mean a lot of sacks, I would expect years of 10+ at least
      Cons: Run D isn't elite, statics don't show much either.
      Pro comp: Dillion Sloan (74)

22. Vincent Benavidez DE 51% B- (basically what ^^ this guy is)
      60-70
      Pros: Max PRT should mean a lot of sacks, I would expect years of 10+ at least

      Cons: Run D isn't elite, PRS isn't huge, End could become an issue. 
      Pro comp: Dillion Sloan (74)

23. Dixon Davison LT 11% B-
      60-70
      Pros: Decent, well balanced 75+ bars in PB, RB and BP, Could be very smart
      Cons: That dev% is a killer, will probably have to sit his first season for most teams.
      Pro comp: Steve Eisner (72)

24. Adam Washington CB 56% B-
     60-70
     Pros: Great Int bar, great zone and BnR. Should be incredibly smart, which is a big +++, and well dev, so can be a starter wk1
     Cons: no run D at all, so no versatility in your DB room. 
     Pro comp: Emmitt Phillips (71)

25. Rondell Albers DT (DE) 33% B-
      60-70
      Pros: Elite RD and Elite pass rush strength. Very smart as well.
      Cons: Looks like a 0 PRS, and End means he wont stay on the field, luxury player. Don't see many studs with no PRS.
      Pro comp: Cesar Harden (67)

26. Evan Harmon FS 56% B-
      60-70
      Pros: Has great RD, so in the right system at SS, he could get 100+ tackles a season. Nice enough coverage bars, great dev%
      Cons: Int bar, don't expect this guy to avg more than 2-3 picks a season.
      Pro comp: Corwin Osborne (68)

27. Griffin Fletcher LT 36% B-
      60-70
      Pros: has a nice bar ratio, a do it all solid LT, with a dev % where you will get a for sure starter by year 2
      Cons: intel, doesn't seem too sharp, but im not sure this is at killer level yet, but its something that does pull him down the board.
      Pro comp: Steve Eisner (72)

28. Roy Conley C 36% B-
      60-70
      Pros: Will be an amazing run blocker, so if you plan to run the ball a lot, this guy is an essential piece. Will have good intel.
      Cons: bad pass blocking, he will let some sacks go.
      Pro comp: Corbin Milne (69)

29. Frederick Dotson LB 67% B-
      55-65
       Pros: all around solid, no weaknesses.
      Cons: Just as he has no weaknesses, he has no real strength.
      Pro comp: Rex King (61)


30. Bart Wickes LB 27% B-
      55-65
      Pros: all around solid, no weaknesses.
      Cons: Just as he has no weaknesses, he has no real strength. 
      Pro comp: Rex King (61)

31. Asher Bridges C 17% B-
      55-65
      Pros: Very smart, and get PB, wont allow sacks.
      Cons: Not great RB, so cant be very effective in the run game
      Pro comp: Ted Morel (70)

32. Brad Bailey CB 28% B-
      55-65
      Pros: Great Int bar, end to play most sets and downs, decent coverage bars.
      Cons: No elite coverage bars.
      Pro comp: Devante McNeil (61)

33. AJ May CB 46% B-
      55-65
      Pros: Return ability is nice, and decent bars, and excellent BnR
      Cons: M2M isn't great, and I like my elite CBs to have a higher zone
      Pro comp: Martin Reynolds (58)

34. Zack Beauchamp WR 13% B-
     50-60
     Pros: Nice RR, could hit 90 if interview is positive. Enough GD to be a good WR2.
     Cons: Once balls in hands, not gonna make too much magic happen.
     Pro comp: Rusty Finley (65)

35. Terrence Smaron WR 11% B-
      50-60
      Pros: Again, has the look of an OK WR2, nothing special, just ok across the board
      Cons: If he sees low side of all the bars, hes wank. Needs a good interview.
      Pro comp: Timothy Humphrey (57)

36.Leonard Lang RB 51% B-
     50-60
     Pros: HR that could be very effective with in the right system
     Cons: not a pure elite RB, more of a system guy.
     Pro comp: Sean Zeyen (63)

37. Sam Moss CB 42% B-
      55-65
      Pros: love that zone, PD and Int combined. And to boot, will be super smart.
      Cons: RD, M2M and End
      Pro comp: Lesser version of Emmitt Phillips (72)

38. Oscar Buchanon G 41% B-
      60-70
      Pros: No real weakness in either blocking department. Max BP
      Cons: End might end up becoming an issue for him later in the season.
      Pro comp: lesser kurt Wells (72) always concerning when I cant find a comp, means the bar pattern doesn't seem to be one that succeeds all too often.

39. RJ Hicks LT 23% B-
      55-65
      Pros: great pass blocker, and can do a very good job blocking for the run.
      Cons: Low BP (bad indicator) and End isn't to shiny either.
      Pro comp: Warren Richardson (63)

40. Maurice Donnelly G 10% B-
      60-70
      Pros: V.good RB, has a bar pattern that ive seen succeed with a lot of Gs. I have him marked as a potential 2nd round steal with late 1st value.
      Cons: dev % and low End.
      Pro comp: Loads, but went with Abel Cloutier (63)

41. Dakota Coles LT 52% C+
      55-65
      Pros: PB and BP, dev% is great and will have no issue making an instant impact.
      Cons: RB potential for him to be not too bright.
      Pro comp: Sebastian Fitzgerald (63)

42. Leland Mason LT (move to G) 37% C+
      55-65
      Pros: size and RB needed to be an elite G
      Cons: Not the smartest dude
      Pro comp: Derek Cerda (65)
 
43. Kris Cote LT (move to G) 35% C+
      55-65
      Pros: size and RB needed to be an elite G, not stupid 
      Cons: Will probably allow a few more sacks than would be liked.
      Pro comp: Charlie Hitchcock (61)

44. Gilbert Duncan FS 27% C+
      55-65
      Pros: Int bar and decent coverage skills.
      Cons: would rather have higher RD and Zone at S, so he is probably a CB
      Pro comp: Donnie Vinnick (63)
  
45. Britt Holtz DT 40% C+
      55-65
      Pros: will stuff the run all day long. Looks smart
      Cons: poor static bars, and end isn't great, would want an interview. Anything negative, this is a no go.
      Pro comp: Elliott Schulz (62)

46. Francisco Reid 25% C+
      55-65
      Pros: Has that bar pattern I like, nice enough RB. Seems smart enough.
      Cons: Not the best pass blocker.
      Pro comp: Abel Cloutier (63)

47. Marco Reynolds CB (move to S) 37% C+
      55-65
      Pros: Max RD, great BnR and Great END.
      Cons: Zone bar is middling. Some people may think he's a little small for conversion.
      Pro comp: Rob Alton (62)
 
48. Jeffery Rivera CB 54% C+
      50-60
      Pros: no specific weakness. BnR and PH are huge (could be lying as they are tied together)
      Cons: Zone, M2M are hovering around 50. 
      Pro comp: Butch Washington without the RD (62)

49. Norman Boccaccio G 13% C+
     55-65
     Pros: Again has the G bar pattern.
     Cons: underdeveloped, it could take 2 whole seasons for this guy to see the field. 
     Pro comp: Abel Cloutier (63)

50. Sammie Mazurek LB 40% C+
     55-65
     Pros: Good RD, good pass coverage, and a max static. Seems to be smart too.
     Cons: Nothing seems specifically elite to GP around, wont specialise in dominating any area.
     Pro comp: Jace Banks (65)

51. Lincoln Kidman DE (move to DE) 41% C+
      55-65
      Pros: Max RD, will be great against the run.
      Cons: Bit of a one trick pony, may not be the smartest.
      Pro comp: Tyrus Pryce (61)

52. Jumbo Carruthers CB 39% C+
      50-60
      Pros: great M2M and Zone with a good INT bar.
      Cons: Endurance, and I don't personally like high PH DBs, as it subtracts from the BnR bar.
      Pro comp: Conner Breese (62)

53. Gabe Hernandez WR 29% C+
      50-60
      Pros: Max RR, makes him a great WR2, nice BPR, enough END
      Cons: GD lacking for him to ever be an elite all pass guy.
      Pro comp: Ezekiel Rigney (57)

54. Kelvin Brubaker G 53% C+
      55-65 
      Pros: great RB, nice enough PB, not stupid.
      Cons: End could become an issue.
      Pro comp: Derek Cerda (65)

55. Skip Easterling LT (move to G) 12% C+
      50-60
      Pros: Good RB, Good BP, nice pattern for G, should be very smart and he is very young.
      Cons: Dev% and End
      Pro comp: Charlie Hitchcock (61)

56. Roosevelt Reese TE 59% C
      50-60
      Pros: 75+ GD will come in handy, RR and BPR aren't the worst. Dev% means wk1 starter.
      Cons: End isn't amazing, not an elite level threat.
      Pro comp: Itula Hackett (60)

57. George Davison LB 40% C
      50-60
      Pros: Great run defender, has plenty of END to always see the field.
      Cons: 2 low statics has me worried. 
      Pro comp: Edward Ross (60)

58. Duane Crane C 38% C
      55-65
      Pros: PRS is maxed, has some RD, good end, good sol
      Cons: PRT isn't elite enough to be a highly effective and dominant pass rusher.
      Pro comp: Stanley Emerson (61)

59. Jared Quiroz S 34% C
      55-65
      Pros: great RD, will have 100+ tackles a season. Great M2M, great INT bar.
      Cons: lack of zone, lack of end, both big no no's for me on a DB
      Pro comp: Rob Alton (62)

60. Ezekiel Ackerman DT 42% C
      50-60
      Pros: Well rounded. OK RD and PRT, max END and max PH.
      Cons: Too heavy to be a DE, RD may not be elite enough to be a top class DT.
      Pro comp: Conner LeBoeuf (59)

61. Elias Mitchell DE 36% C
      50-60
      Pros: Good run D, nice statics, very young 20yo
      Cons: wont get the number of sacks you would really wanting from a starting DE IMO.
      Pro comp: Randall Springer (64)
 
62. Hunter Rincon FB 13% C
      55-65
      Pros: Has some good receiving bars, and would be good in use as a number 2 TE
      Cons: running bars aren't where id want
      Pro comp: none, everyone converts TE's 

63. Jaylen Abrams DE 19% C
      50-60
      Pros: Good run D, nice statics, max END 
      Cons: wont get the number of sacks you would really wanting from a starting DE IMO.

      Pro comp: Randall Springer (64)

64. JB Burnett G 15% C
      50-60
      Pros: If his bars are to believed, he could be an early 3rd, late 2nd steal
      Cons: Not the smartest, think his bars are lying
      Pro comp: Rondell Petruziello (67)
  
65. Jeremy Heath DE 26% C 
      50-60 
      Pros: Good run D, nice statics, seems to not be dumb
      Cons: wont get the number of sacks you would really wanting from a starting DE IMO. A little old with that dev%
      Pro comp: Randall Springer (64)

66. Oscar Fitzgerald DE 36% C
      50-60
      Pros: Could be an OK pass rusher with 75ish PRT
      Cons: Not a true elite pass rusher, RD is lacking.
      Pro comp: Bryant King (59)

67. Wally Castagnola DT 43% C
      55-65
      Pros: RD and PRT are both insane
      Cons: no END, not very smart.
      Pro comp: Broderick Dawson (60)

68. Brent Bernard FB 37% C VO
      50-60
      Pros: HR and RR
      Cons: 3rd down running, and very overrated, which is a shame as he was someone I was seriously considering trying hard to go and get.
      Pro comp: No one, there are no FBs really.

69. Ray Childers TE 38% C
      50-60
      Pros: has some RR and GD to be an effective TE2
      Cons: BPR hovering around 50
      Pro comp: Scottie Brown (53)

70. Kris Wheeler CB 64% C
      50-60
      Pros: INT bar, BnR bar and dev%
      Cons: lack of END, no PD
      Pro comp: Donnie Vinnick (63) without endurance

71. Leonardo Campbell RB 61% C
      50-60
      Pros: not bad in any running area, enough end to take lots of snaps.
      Cons: HR wont have him looking elite IMO.
      Pro comp: Sean Zeyen (63)

72. Amir Pierce FS 57% C
     50-60
     Pros: great RD and max Zone. Long time SS starter in the league. Smart
     Cons: BnR, and Int bar
     Pro comp: Vince Aronovitch (60)

73. Lucas Hickman G 13% C O
      50-55
      Pros: Good RB, OK PB 
      Cons: Dev%, END and the interview.
      Pro comp: Monty Watters (53)

74. Willie Packer DE 45% C
      50-60
      Pros: Well first off, that incredible name, and his PRT, a possible 10+ sack a year dude
      Cons: End, RD and statics 
      Pro comp: Peyton Galloway (50)
 
75. Damien Leitsch DT 29% C
     50-60
     Pros: OK RD, PRT is around 75, may get a few sacks
     Cons: Weight might mean he cant be converted to DE, and his RD bar isn't good enough to be just a DT 
     Pro comp: Bryant King (59)

76. Sebastian Fanning CB (move to S) 46% C
      50-60
      Pros: Max RD, max BnR and returning ability
      Cons: End, M2M and Zone are lacking
      Pro comp: Rob Alton (62)

77. Richard Merrill RB 64% C-
      50-60
      Pros: great HR, 3rd down running and elusiveness
      Cons: those statics, makes it hard to believe in his other bars.
      Pro comp: Fred Garcia (51) with more HR

78. Gilbert Venegas LB 26% C-
      50-60
      Pros: RD is ok, some PRT, but his intel is a big bonus in boosting his value to me, dude is smart
      Cons: End and pass coverage bars
      Pro comp: If anyone can find one, let me know (smh)

79. Duane Booker WR 19% C-
      45-55
      Pros: RR and GD look decent enough
      Cons: BPR is a worry, lack of dev% 
      Pro comp: Joshua Berman (50)

80. Doug DeVault WR 23% C-
      45-55
      Pros: RR is good, GD will do, has a good amount of END
      Cons: BPR is lacking, the dude is dumb, good job he will get drafted.
      Pro comp: Ron Lerma (53)